The Double-Edged Sword of Selenium Supplementation

Oct 28 / Drs. Bryan & Julie Walsh

Introduction

Selenium is a trace mineral with a crucial role in health, supporting antioxidant defense, immune regulation, and thyroid function. However, while selenium is essential, its benefits are not as simple as “more is better.” Research increasingly shows that while low selenium levels may lead to adverse effects, excessive intake introduces its own set of risks, including a higher likelihood of type 2 diabetes, undesirable changes in lipid profiles, and even oxidative damage when taken in large doses.

For clinicians, this creates a balancing act. Selenium’s functions are undeniably valuable, but its impact varies widely based on individual status. This article examines selenium’s physiological roles, the fine line between optimal and excessive intake, and offers practical recommendations for assessing and managing selenium in clinical practice. With a nuanced approach, clinicians can help patients gain the benefits of selenium while sidestepping the risks that come with indiscriminate supplementation.

Selenium's Biological Roles: More Than Just an Antioxidant

Selenium is a trace element that plays crucial roles in human health, primarily through its incorporation into selenoproteins. These specialized proteins are involved in various physiological processes, with antioxidant defense and thyroid hormone regulation being among the most significant.

Selenoproteins: The Workhorses of Selenium Function

Selenoproteins are unique in that they contain selenocysteine, often referred to as the 21st amino acid. This incorporation of selenium allows these proteins to perform specialized functions that are essential for optimal health. Two major classes of selenoproteins deserve particular attention:

  1. Glutathione Peroxidases (GPx): These enzymes form a critical part of the body's antioxidant defense system. GPx enzymes help protect cellular components from oxidative damage by neutralizing hydrogen peroxide and lipid hydroperoxides. This protection is particularly important in tissues with high metabolic activity, such as the thyroid gland.

  2. Iodothyronine Deiodinases: These enzymes play a pivotal role in thyroid hormone metabolism. They are responsible for converting the prohormone thyroxine (T4) to its active form, triiodothyronine (T3), as well as for inactivating thyroid hormones when necessary. This fine-tuning of thyroid hormone levels is crucial for maintaining proper metabolic function throughout the body.

"Selenium’s effects are powerful yet paradoxical—while it’s essential for thyroid health and antioxidant defense, excessive intake doesn’t provide additional benefits and may, in fact, increase health risks.."

The Selenium-Thyroid Connection

The thyroid gland contains the highest concentration of selenium per gram of tissue in the human body, highlighting its importance in thyroid function. Selenium is not only necessary for the conversion of T4 to T3 but also protects the thyroid gland from oxidative stress generated during hormone synthesis.

Research has shown that selenium deficiency can impair thyroid function and may contribute to the development or progression of thyroid disorders. A study by Köhrle et al. demonstrated that selenoproteins in the thyroid gland scavenge excess hydrogen peroxide produced during hormone synthesis, thus protecting thyroid cells from oxidative damage. [1]

Beyond Thyroid Function: Selenium's Role in Immune Regulation

Selenium also plays a significant role in immune function. It is involved in the regulation of both innate and adaptive immune responses. Adequate selenium status has been associated with enhanced immune cell proliferation, increased natural killer cell activity, and improved cytokine production. [2]
A meta-analysis by Wang et al. found that selenium supplementation was associated with a reduced risk of certain infections, particularly in individuals with low selenium status. [3] However, it's important to note that these benefits were primarily observed in populations with suboptimal selenium levels, highlighting the importance of targeted supplementation rather than a one-size-fits-all approach.

Assessing Selenium Status: The Importance of Accurate Measurement

Given the critical roles of selenium in human health, accurate assessment of selenium status is crucial for identifying individuals who may benefit from supplementation and those who are at risk of excessive intake. While several methods exist for evaluating selenium status, serum selenium concentration remains the most practical and widely used approach in clinical settings.

Serum Selenium: The Gold Standard for Clinical Assessment

Serum selenium concentration provides a reliable indicator of short-term selenium status and is relatively easy to measure. The following ranges are generally used to interpret serum selenium levels:
  • Deficient: < 70-90 µg/L
  • Optimal: 100-120 µg/L
  • Potentially toxic: > 400 µg/L
It's important to note that these ranges may vary slightly depending on the specific laboratory and population being studied. A study by Rayman et al. found that serum selenium concentrations below 85 µg/L were associated with increased risk of adverse health outcomes, while levels above 120 µg/L did not confer additional benefits. [4]

Limitations of Dietary Assessment

While dietary intake is an important factor in determining selenium status, it is not a reliable indicator on its own. The selenium content of foods can vary widely based on several factors:
  1. Soil conditions: The selenium content of plants is directly related to the selenium content of the soil in which they are grown. This can lead to significant regional variations in dietary selenium intake.

  2. Food processing: Certain food processing methods can affect the selenium content of foods.

  3. Bioavailability: The form of selenium in foods (organic vs. inorganic) can affect its absorption and utilization by the body.
Given these variables, relying solely on dietary intake to assess selenium status can be misleading. A study by Vinceti et al. highlighted the limitations of dietary assessment methods and emphasized the importance of using biomarkers like serum selenium for accurate status determination. [5]

Advanced Biomarkers: Beyond Serum Selenium

While serum selenium is the most practical measure for clinical use, researchers have explored other biomarkers that may provide additional insights into selenium status:
  1. Plasma selenoprotein P: This protein is considered a functional biomarker of selenium status, as it reflects the body's selenium utilization. However, its measurement is not widely available in clinical settings.

  2. Erythrocyte selenium: This measure reflects longer-term selenium status but is less responsive to recent changes in intake.

  3. Urinary selenium: While easy to collect, urinary selenium is more reflective of recent intake rather than overall status.
For most clinical applications, serum selenium remains the most practical and informative measure of selenium status. Clinicians should be aware of the limitations of dietary assessment and focus on serum levels when evaluating the need for selenium supplementation.

Risks of Excessive Intake: When More Is Not Better

While selenium deficiency is a concern in some parts of the world, excessive intake through indiscriminate supplementation is becoming an increasingly common issue in developed countries. This trend is particularly worrisome given the growing body of evidence suggesting that high selenium status may be associated with adverse health outcomes.

The Paradox of Selenium Supplementation

The popularity of selenium supplements has grown in recent years, driven by claims of antioxidant benefits and potential cancer prevention. However, research has shown that the relationship between selenium intake and health outcomes is not linear, and excessive intake can lead to unintended consequences.

Type 2 Diabetes Risk

One of the most concerning findings related to high selenium status is its association with an increased risk of type 2 diabetes. A landmark study by Stranges et al. found that selenium supplementation at 200 µg/day increased the risk of type 2 diabetes by 50% in individuals with high baseline selenium levels. [6] This finding was particularly striking as it came from a randomized controlled trial initially designed to investigate selenium's potential cancer-preventive effects.

The mechanism behind this increased diabetes risk is not fully understood, but it may be related to selenium's effects on insulin signaling and glucose homeostasis. Excessive selenium intake may interfere with insulin-dependent glucose uptake and disrupt normal glucose metabolism.

Lipid Profile Alterations

High selenium status has also been associated with unfavorable changes in blood lipid profiles. A meta-analysis by Rayman et al. found that selenium supplementation was associated with increases in total cholesterol and LDL cholesterol levels. [7] These changes in lipid profiles could potentially increase the risk of cardiovascular disease, although more research is needed to fully elucidate this relationship.

Prostate Cancer Risk

While early studies suggested that selenium might have a protective effect against prostate cancer, more recent research has called this into question. The Selenium and Vitamin E Cancer Prevention Trial (SELECT) found no benefit of selenium supplementation in preventing prostate cancer. In fact, there was a non-significant increase in prostate cancer risk among men with high baseline selenium levels who received selenium supplements. [8]

Mechanisms of Selenium Toxicity

The toxic effects of excessive selenium intake are thought to be mediated through several mechanisms:
  1. Pro-oxidant effects: At high concentrations, selenium can act as a pro-oxidant rather than an antioxidant, leading to oxidative stress and cellular damage.

  2. Disruption of redox signaling: Excessive selenium can interfere with normal redox signaling pathways, which are important for various cellular functions.

  3. Interference with other trace elements: High selenium intake may interfere with the metabolism and utilization of other essential trace elements, such as zinc and copper.

  4. Selenosis: In extreme cases, excessive selenium intake can lead to selenosis, characterized by hair loss, nail brittleness, gastrointestinal disturbances, and neurological symptoms.

"The relationship between selenium and health follows a U-shaped curve, where both deficiency and excess can lead to adverse outcomes, making targeted, individualized supplementation crucial."

The Importance of Targeted Supplementation

Given the potential risks associated with excessive selenium intake, it is crucial that clinicians adopt a targeted approach to selenium supplementation. This means assessing individual selenium status through serum selenium measurements and recommending supplementation only when there is clear evidence of deficiency.

For most individuals in developed countries with adequate selenium intake from their diet, routine selenium supplementation is unnecessary and may be harmful. The focus should be on achieving optimal selenium status through a balanced diet rich in selenium-containing foods, rather than relying on supplements.

The U-Shaped Relationship: Finding the Sweet Spot for Selenium Status

The relationship between selenium status and health outcomes is not linear but rather follows a U-shaped curve. This complex relationship underscores the importance of maintaining optimal selenium levels and highlights the potential risks associated with both deficiency and excess.

Understanding the U-Shaped Curve

The U-shaped relationship between selenium status and health outcomes can be visualized as follows:

This curve illustrates that both low and high selenium status are associated with increased health risks, while optimal status is associated with the lowest risk. (Rayman, M.P. Selenium intake, status, and health: a complex relationship. Hormones 19, 9–14 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1007/s42000-019-00125-5)

Evidence for the U-Shaped Relationship

Several studies have provided evidence for this U-shaped relationship across various health outcomes:
  1. Mortality: A meta-analysis by Rayman et al. found that both low and high serum selenium concentrations were associated with increased all-cause mortality. [9] The lowest mortality risk was observed at serum selenium levels between 130-150 µg/L.

  2. Cardiovascular Disease: Research by Bleys et al. demonstrated a U-shaped association between serum selenium and cardiovascular disease risk, with both low and high levels associated with increased risk. [10]

  3. Cancer: While selenium deficiency has been associated with increased cancer risk, excessive intake has not shown additional protective effects and may even increase risk for certain cancers, as seen in the SELECT trial. [8]

Implications for Supplementation

The U-shaped relationship between selenium status and health outcomes has important implications for selenium supplementation:
  1. Targeted Supplementation: Supplementation is likely to be beneficial only for individuals with low selenium status. Those with adequate or high status may not benefit and could potentially be harmed by additional intake.

  2. Personalized Approach: Given the variability in individual selenium requirements and metabolism, a one-size-fits-all approach to supplementation is not appropriate. Serum selenium testing should guide supplementation decisions.

  3. Monitoring: For individuals receiving selenium supplements, regular monitoring of serum selenium levels is important to ensure that optimal status is maintained without reaching potentially harmful levels.

  4. Consideration of Other Factors: The optimal selenium status may vary depending on factors such as age, sex, health status, concurrent nutrient deficiencies (e.g., iodine status for thyroid function), and demographic location.

Challenges in Defining Optimal Status

While the concept of a U-shaped relationship is well-established, defining the exact optimal range for selenium status remains challenging. Factors contributing to this challenge include:
  1. Population Differences: Optimal selenium status may vary between populations due to genetic factors, dietary patterns, and environmental exposures (Figure 2).

  2. Health Outcome Specificity: The optimal range may differ depending on the specific health outcome being considered (e.g., thyroid function vs. cancer risk).

  3. Interactions with Other Nutrients: Selenium's effects may be modulated by the status of other nutrients, particularly iodine in the case of thyroid function.

  4. Methodological Variations: Differences in study designs, selenium assessment methods, and outcome measures can lead to variations in reported optimal ranges.
Despite these challenges, current evidence suggests that for most health outcomes, serum selenium concentrations between 100-120 µg/L are associated with optimal health benefits while minimizing risks.

Selenium and Thyroid Function: A Delicate Balance

The relationship between selenium and thyroid function is complex and multifaceted. While selenium is essential for proper thyroid hormone metabolism, excessive intake does not necessarily lead to improved thyroid function and may even have detrimental effects.

Selenium's Role in Thyroid Physiology

Selenium plays several crucial roles in thyroid physiology:
  1. Iodothyronine Deiodinases: These selenoenzymes are responsible for converting the prohormone thyroxine (T4) to its active form, triiodothyronine (T3), as well as for inactivating thyroid hormones when necessary.

  2. Antioxidant Protection: Selenoproteins, particularly glutathione peroxidases, protect the thyroid gland from oxidative stress generated during hormone synthesis.

  3. Thyroid Hormone Receptor Function: Selenium is involved in the proper functioning of thyroid hormone receptors, influencing the cellular response to thyroid hormones.

The Impact of Selenium Status on Thyroid Function

Research has shown that selenium status can significantly impact thyroid function:
  1. Selenium Deficiency: Low selenium status has been associated with impaired thyroid hormone metabolism, increased risk of thyroid autoimmunity, and potentially increased risk of thyroid cancer. [11]

  2. Adequate Selenium Status: Maintaining optimal selenium levels is crucial for normal thyroid function and may help prevent or mitigate certain thyroid disorders.

  3. Excessive Selenium Intake: Contrary to popular belief, high-dose selenium supplementation does not necessarily improve thyroid function in individuals with adequate selenium status and may even have negative effects.

The Paradox of High-Dose Selenium Supplementation

While selenium supplementation can be beneficial in cases of deficiency, excessive intake may paradoxically impair thyroid function. A study by Winther et al. found that high-dose selenium supplementation (300 µg/day) in euthyroid adults with adequate selenium status led to a decrease in serum T3 levels and an increase in reverse T3, potentially indicating impaired thyroid hormone activation. [12]

This finding highlights the importance of maintaining optimal, rather than maximal, selenium status for thyroid health. The mechanisms behind this paradoxical effect may include:
  1. Overactivation of Deiodinases: Excessive selenium intake may lead to increased activity of type 3 deiodinase, which inactivates thyroid hormones.

  2. Disruption of Redox Balance: High selenium levels may alter the redox balance within thyroid cells, potentially interfering with normal hormone synthesis and metabolism.

  3. Interference with Iodine Utilization: Some research suggests that very high selenium intake may interfere with iodine uptake and utilization by the thyroid gland.

Selenium Supplementation in Thyroid Disorders

The role of selenium supplementation in various thyroid disorders has been a subject of considerable research:
  1. Autoimmune Thyroiditis: Some studies have shown that selenium supplementation may reduce thyroid autoantibody levels and improve quality of life in patients with autoimmune thyroiditis. However, the clinical significance of these findings remains debated. [13]

  2. Graves' Disease: Selenium supplementation may help improve outcomes in patients with mild Graves' ophthalmopathy, but its role in the management of Graves' disease itself is less clear. [14]

  3. Thyroid Cancer: While adequate selenium status is important for thyroid health, there is currently insufficient evidence to support selenium supplementation for thyroid cancer prevention or treatment.

Practical Considerations for Clinicians

When considering selenium supplementation for thyroid health, clinicians should keep the following points in mind:
  1. Assess Selenium Status: Measure serum selenium levels before recommending supplementation. Supplementation is likely to be beneficial only in cases of true deficiency.

  2. Consider Iodine Status: The interplay between selenium and iodine is crucial for thyroid function. Ensure adequate iodine status before initiating selenium supplementation.

  3. Use Appropriate Dosages: If supplementation is necessary, use moderate doses (50-100 µg/day) rather than high doses, which may be counterproductive.

  4. Monitor Thyroid Function: Regularly assess thyroid function in patients receiving selenium supplements, as changes in selenium status can affect thyroid hormone levels.

  5. Individualize Treatment: Consider the patient's overall health status, concurrent medications, and specific thyroid condition when making decisions about selenium supplementation.
By taking a nuanced approach to selenium supplementation in thyroid health, clinicians can help patients achieve optimal thyroid function while minimizing the risks associated with excessive intake.

Practical Recommendations: A Balanced Approach to Selenium Intake

Given the complex relationship between selenium status and health outcomes, it is crucial for clinicians to adopt a balanced and evidence-based approach to selenium intake and supplementation. The following recommendations provide a framework for assessing and managing selenium status in clinical practice.

1. Assess Selenium Status

Before considering selenium supplementation, it is essential to assess the patient's current selenium status:
  • Serum Selenium Testing: This is the most practical and widely available method for assessing selenium status in clinical settings. Aim for serum selenium levels between 100-120 µg/L, which is generally considered the optimal range for most health outcomes.

  • Consider Regional Variations: Be aware of regional differences in selenium intake due to variations in soil selenium content. Patients from areas known to have low soil selenium may be at higher risk of deficiency.

2. Evaluate Dietary Intake

While not as reliable as serum testing, assessing dietary selenium intake can provide valuable context:
  • Food Frequency Questionnaire: Use a validated food frequency questionnaire that includes selenium-rich foods to estimate dietary intake.

  • Key Selenium Sources: Focus on major dietary sources of selenium, including:
    • Brazil nuts (highest natural source)
    • Seafood (particularly tuna, halibut, sardines)
    • Organ meats
    • Whole grains
    • Poultry
    • Eggs

3. Consider Individual Factors

Several individual factors can influence selenium requirements and metabolism:
  • Age: Older adults may have increased selenium needs due to reduced absorption and increased oxidative stress.

  • Pregnancy and Lactation: Increased selenium requirements during these periods.

  • Chronic Diseases: Certain conditions (e.g., HIV, chronic kidney disease) may affect selenium metabolism.

  • Medications: Some medications can interfere with selenium absorption or increase requirements.

4. Supplementation Guidelines

If supplementation is deemed necessary based on serum selenium levels and individual factors:
  • Dosage: Start with a moderate dose of 50-100 µg/day. Higher doses are rarely necessary and may be harmful.

  • Form: Organic forms of selenium (e.g., selenomethionine) are generally better absorbed than inorganic forms.

  • Duration: Plan for short-term supplementation with regular monitoring. Long-term supplementation should only be considered in cases of persistent deficiency.

  • Monitoring: Recheck serum selenium levels after 3-6 months of supplementation to ensure optimal status has been achieved without overshooting into potentially harmful ranges.

5. Emphasize Dietary Sources

For most individuals, dietary sources should be the primary means of achieving optimal selenium status:
  • Balanced Diet: Encourage a varied diet rich in selenium-containing foods.

  • Brazil Nuts: A single Brazil nut can provide 68-91 µg of selenium, making it an excellent natural source. However, caution patients against excessive consumption, as just a few nuts can exceed the upper tolerable intake level.

  • Seafood: Promote regular consumption of seafood, which is not only rich in selenium but also provides other beneficial nutrients like omega-3 fatty acids.

6. Educate Patients on Risks of Excessive Intake

It's crucial to inform patients about the potential risks associated with excessive selenium intake:
  • Supplement Caution: Warn against self-supplementation without professional guidance.

  • Multivitamin Awareness: Remind patients to check the selenium content of their multivitamin supplements, as these can contribute significantly to total intake.

  • Symptoms of Excess: Educate patients on signs of selenium toxicity, including garlic breath odor, hair loss, nail brittleness, and gastrointestinal symptoms.

7. Special Considerations for Thyroid Patients

For patients with thyroid disorders:
  • Autoimmune Thyroiditis: Consider a trial of selenium supplementation (200 µg/day) for 3-6 months in patients with autoimmune thyroiditis and elevated thyroid antibodies, monitoring both selenium levels and thyroid function.

  • Graves' Disease: Selenium supplementation may be beneficial in mild Graves' ophthalmopathy but should be used cautiously and under close monitoring.

  • Iodine Status: Always consider iodine status in conjunction with selenium status when managing thyroid disorders.

8. Regular Reassessment

Selenium status and requirements can change over time:
  • Annual Screening: Consider annual serum selenium screening for high-risk individuals or those on long-term supplementation.

  • Dietary Changes: Reassess selenium status if significant changes occur in dietary patterns or overall health status.
By following these practical recommendations, clinicians can help patients achieve and maintain optimal selenium status while minimizing the risks associated with both deficiency and excess. This balanced approach aligns with the principle of personalized nutrition and recognizes the importance of targeted, evidence-based interventions in clinical practice.

Conclusion 

Selenium, an essential trace element, plays crucial roles in human health, particularly in thyroid function, antioxidant defense, and immune regulation. However, the relationship between selenium status and health outcomes is complex and follows a U-shaped curve, where both deficiency and excess can lead to adverse effects.

The growing trend of indiscriminate selenium supplementation in functional medicine and nutrition circles is concerning, given the potential risks associated with excessive intake. Research has shown that high selenium status may increase the risk of type 2 diabetes, unfavorable lipid profiles, and potentially certain cancers. Moreover, excessive selenium intake does not necessarily improve thyroid function in individuals with adequate status and may even impair it.

Clinicians must adopt a balanced, evidence-based approach to selenium management. Serum selenium testing is the most practical method for assessing status, with levels between 100-120 µg/L generally considered optimal. Supplementation should be reserved for cases of true deficiency, and when necessary, moderate doses (50-100 µg/day) should be used with regular monitoring.

For most individuals, achieving optimal selenium status through a balanced diet rich in selenium-containing foods like Brazil nuts, seafood, and whole grains is preferable to supplementation. This approach minimizes the risks associated with excessive intake while ensuring adequate selenium for optimal health.

In the context of thyroid health, while selenium is crucial for proper thyroid function, high-dose supplementation in individuals with adequate status may be counterproductive. Clinicians should consider selenium status in conjunction with iodine status and overall thyroid function when managing thyroid disorders.

The key message is clear: more is not always better when it comes to selenium. By moving away from the "more is better" approach and towards targeted, personalized interventions based on accurate assessment of selenium status, clinicians can help patients achieve optimal health outcomes while minimizing potential risks.

Future research should focus on refining our understanding of optimal selenium status for different populations and health conditions, as well as exploring the long-term effects of various levels of selenium intake. In the meantime, a cautious and individualized approach to selenium management remains the best practice for clinicians and patients alike.

Chris

"This should be 101 level teaching for anyone studying to be a healthcare practitioner. I tremendously appreciate the insights presented here." 

Dr Kang

“Extremely helpful. I have been wondering what could be the balancing pivot for especially older adults who should be ingesting slightly higher amounts of protein but yet be able to mitigate age-related bone loss risks. This clinical content session answered the question. Dr. Walsh has done it again, by translating evidence-based insights into practical clinical implementation that we could use immediately.”

Learn this, and so much more in our clinical mentorship, Clinician's Code Foundation Professional Certificate where we help practitioners build confidence, cut overwhelm, and become successful in Functional Medicine.

Sadie

"I LOVE everything about these presentations. It makes me excited to practice. 😊"

Carrie

"This is incredible information Dr Walsh."

Fernando

"Another outstanding presentation...
Thank you!"

Khaled

"You ground me from all the FM Hype out there, which is mostly messy, biased, and FOMO driven. Please keep doing what you're doing. Your work is benefiting so many patients around the globe. Truly blessed to be amongst your students. Much love ❤️"